‘Last-Minute Win’: Just 4 ingredients. I throw this together every New Year.

For kids who are sensitive to strong flavors, you can use mild cheddar instead of sharp, and reduce or skip the garlic powder for a gentler taste. If your family enjoys a little kick, stir in a pinch of cayenne pepper or a few dashes of hot sauce. For extra creaminess, you can replace a couple of tablespoons of the mayonnaise with softened cream cheese (this technically adds another ingredient, but it’s a nice upgrade for special occasions). If you have picky eaters who don’t like the texture of pimentos, pulse the pimentos briefly in a food processor or chop them very finely so they blend in more smoothly. You can also use this as a grilled cheese filling—spread it between two slices of bread and toast in a skillet for a fun twist on a classic sandwich. To lighten it up a bit, swap part of the mayonnaise for plain Greek yogurt; start with half mayo and half yogurt and adjust to your family’s taste.